- Gnome Stew - https://gnomestew.com -

First Time GM – Game Prep II – Techniques

First Time GM is a series of articles dedicated to the newly-minted game master, making his or her first tentative die rolls behind the screen. Today’s article deals with techniques used to prepare for a game. A broader look at the process is here [1].

GMing is an art form; no two GMs will prepare in exactly the same manner. In addition, the list of techniques for game prep is massive and ever-changing. I’ll try to cover a few big topics, but each GM have to find what works best for them.

First Time Out

For truly first-time GMs, I strongly recommend a published adventure. Preferably one by the writers of the game, for low-level play, using pre-generated characters, and where player choices are somewhat limited (like a dungeon crawl).

Published adventures, especially ones by the writers of the system, are usually balanced, usually point out some of the cooler parts of the game system, and (most importantly) have been playtested to ensure that the players should enjoy it.

Low level play is much easier to manage than high level, especially for the GM. Encounters tend to take less time, which is good, because novice GMs should take their time learning the rules. Low level monsters, traps, and characters have less information to clog up your already full memory banks.

Unless your group is already comfortable with the rules system, pre-generated characters are the best way to go. Many systems will have character generation pitfalls that aren’t obvious until after the game has started (such as the broad but very limited abilities of generalists), and pre-gens will usually avoid these pitfalls. Also, you want to run a game, not sit there for an hour while the players argue over who has to play the cleric this time.

Limiting the players’ choices is somewhat ‘railroadish [2]’, but getting behind the screen is confusing enough. For the first few times behind the screen, it’s best to keep the action somewhat predictable and well-defined. Save the free-form ‘sandbox [3]’ style for later.

When using a published adventure, read it cover-to-cover twice. Highlight important passages. Make notes in the margin or on a notepad. Run a ‘test encounter’ to see the rules in play. Create a rough playbook for important NPCs – Which ability will they use first? Under what conditions will they retreat? How open to negotiations are they? Get comfortable enough with the adventure to know where to find the important points when the party gets to them. If it helps, use post-it notes or adhesive flags to mark important rules in the core books.

Rolling Your Own

Once the initial adventures are over, many GMs are eager to to take the reins and start their own campaigns. Some stick with published ‘adventure paths’, while others prefer to start entirely from scratch, either in an established setting, or in one of their own creation. I suggest sticking to the published material when possible, at least until you’re comfortable behind the screen.

Regardless, there are a few general techniques for game prep:

Before the Game

The day before the game, I like to review the rules for any new weapons, spells, critters, etc that I or the players will be using this session. Too many games have ground to a halt while the group looks up and argues about how the new ‘thing’ actually works.

The day of the game, I scan my notes, remind myself of the important points in each scene or for each NPC, and try to take a few minutes before the game to relax and ‘get into character’ as it were. A few minutes’ relaxation before a game can make all the difference between a mediocre session and a great one.

During and After the Game

Your prep may be over once the players arrive, but the acid test is just beginning. During the game, make notes to yourself about how your prep and notes worked, and especially what didn’t work. Did the structure work? Do you prefer the critters’ stats on the page of the room they’re in, or collected in an appendix in the back? Did your chosen ‘stat block’ format work for you? Did you prep everything you needed, and need everything you prepped?

Don’t be too harsh on yourself, but be aware of what didn’t work, and make an effort to change it up the next time around. Feel free to try out new techniques and see what works for you.

Do you have any favorite prep techniques or anything else to add? Sound off in the comments and let us know!

10 Comments (Open | Close)

10 Comments To "First Time GM – Game Prep II – Techniques"

#1 Comment By Noumenon On October 13, 2010 @ 7:31 am

Create a rough playbook for important NPCs – Which ability will they use first? Under what conditions will they retreat? How open to negotiations are they?

Goodman Games’ Castle Whiterock is exemplary for doing all of this for you. Really, it ought to be the module’s job.

The single most important step in my read-through of a module is to take the map and mark on it where the monsters are in each room. Just placing that X on the map makes the difference between “I’m reading this module like it was a story about a dungeon” and “I’m actually envisioning how this room will work in the game.” I read through Castle Whiterock two or three times before running it without retaining as much as that one time through marking X’s on the map.

#2 Comment By Kurt “Telas” Schneider On October 13, 2010 @ 10:34 am

[6] – Thanks! It’s good to see that well-designed adventures are still being written.

Also, I should have added – Whatever mistakes you may make, don’t take it too seriously. It’s just a game.

#3 Comment By Roxysteve On October 13, 2010 @ 12:59 pm

Good advice throughout, but examples are for the D&D GM. What about the first timer who is running a game outside that Genre? What if there are no dungeons to crawl? :o)

Spot on advice about the published adventure there. I’m often surprised that more RPG rulebooks don’t come with just such an intro scenario to show the new GM what it’s all about.

One of the nice catches by the designers of Call of Cthulhu (Sandy Petersen primarily in this case) was the inclusion of what just about everyone calls the “Corbitt House Scenario” (but which is actually called “The Haunted House” in current editions due to Title Collision with another scenario) from First edition on. A great intro, if a little light on what differentiates Call of Cthulhu from the rest of the pack. I still run it for new players 30 years on.

I was very surprised that Mongoose didn’t include an intro scenario for “Conan” in the rulebook to demo why Conan wasn’t just D&D without Hobbits-sorry-Halflings. I think the best short adventure for that game out there is “Tower of the Elephant” for anyone who cares.

Anyway, this is a great series of articles, but I think that probably the advice most new GMs need most of all is “read Gnome Stew”, since there don’t seem to be many comments from new GMs, the target audience. This suggests to me that new GMs simply don’t know GS is here.

I could be wrong, and the articles could be so clear and persuasive they need no comments from new GMs at all.

And yes, I do recommend Gnome Stew to anyone I think is likely to be in the market for good GM ideas when I meet ’em face-to-face.

#4 Comment By Kurt “Telas” Schneider On October 13, 2010 @ 1:13 pm

[7] – Thanks for the kudos! I was frustrated by the lack of comments on the series, until a fellow Gnome pointed out that it’s not necessarily a bad thing…

While there may not be dungeons to crawl in other games, there are certainly abandoned spaceships to salvage, haunted houses to investigate, enemy compounds to raid, murders to solve on running trains, etc. The key is that the environment limits player choice, so newbie GMs aren’t forced to improvise when the party veers off course.

#5 Comment By Razjah On October 13, 2010 @ 4:04 pm

I think that the D&D examples work great. Just about everyone getting into rpgs knows about D&D and it is probably what game they were introduced on. Maybe on the next installment you can use some other examples to give help to new GMs who don’t do D&D.

#6 Comment By ggodo On October 13, 2010 @ 7:51 pm

[7] – As a fairly new GM, I’m just lacking in ideas to add. Many of these have been pretty awesome.
Now if only the homebrew Left 4e Dead My game group is working on ever gets close to done we’ll be pretty awesome.

#7 Comment By Kurt “Telas” Schneider On October 13, 2010 @ 8:29 pm

Gah! I was just cleaning up my notes for this and realized that most of the last section is a re-write of something Martin wrote when I asked some Gnomes for prep advice for this article. In writing it, I cut his name from the section, and never properly attributed it.

So: Belated credit for the “During and After the Game” section goes to Martin Ralya.

#8 Comment By Roxysteve On October 14, 2010 @ 8:02 am

[8] – Too late! No retcons!

#9 Comment By Roxysteve On October 14, 2010 @ 8:06 am

[9] – Quick Tip: For adventure ideas, don’t limit your thinking to the Left for Dead sources. Search other game sites for free adventure downloads and see if they can’t be bashed with the Story Hammer into something fit for purpose. This will get you and your players into the water faster which will build player demand for your GMing sessions.

#10 Comment By Roxysteve On October 14, 2010 @ 8:12 am

[7] – I was being ironic: There are *always* dungeons to crawl because the houses, derelict starships etc are just dungeons in disguise, and underground cavern complexes are so evocative and enjoyable for players that they abound in just about every RPG genre in some adventure or other.

That point you made about limiting choice is key, and it applies across the spectrum of player experience too. The tensest games/movies are those in which the participants cannot choose not to participate in events. Of course, then you can have Van Helsing Syndrome where players would actually develop psychosomatic dysentery or injure themselves to escape the game/movie.

#11 Pingback By Ravenous Role Playing » Blog Archive » Friday Five: 2010-10-15 On October 15, 2010 @ 5:24 pm

[…] First Time GM – Game Prep II – Techniques […]