I think you’re right, and that discussion is worth having. The first games clearly did something right; there’s a reason I’m at work but I’ve got the 3.5 product City of Brass sitting here, emblazoned with Necromancer Games’s motto: “Third Edition Rules, First Edition Feel.”

That’s a much better line than, “Get together, roll some dice, have some fun,” (positively mediocre marketing), but the sentiment is still there.

By “era,” I mean the time before us nerds had so many outlets for our interests. There were sci-fi and fantasy novels, comics, movies, TV… But no RPGs or video games (to speak of). I think of my own experience in the early 90s as a microcosm of geek exposure to RPGs two decades earlier – I found D&D and discovered I hadn’t known what I was missing. There was suddenly a whole new world of imagination gaming available to me that I hadn’t known, so loving it was never in question.

Fast-forward 15 years. I walk into a game stores and see game after game that features beautiful artwork, elegant rules, and strong online support. If I were looking into a new game and hadn’t played the “classic” D&D before, I wouldn’t consider it now.

The classic games often feature awkward brainfart rules, an emphasis on technicalities rather than elegance, poor art, etc.

Martin said something the other day (relating to our own group in Utah) that came to my mind in reading this article: “Playing 4e put the final nail in 3.x’s coffin for me.” I think that sums up a lot of the change in the RPG community’s evolution over the last 30 years (even if I only experienced half of it). When we had less choice, we tolerated more. Now that we have such an incredible diversity of gaming choices, our tastes are becoming more refined, and we demand much more from the games we play.

All that said, I’m not arguing that the old games have nothing to offer. I think one of the best offerings from the classics is how fully they embrace the kind of reckless, unpretentious fun that many games today miss. A monk, an assassin, and a knight murdering their way through orcs in a volcano? Giant-hamster powered ships flying through phlogiston? You’re certainly not going to find that in Monster: The Modernizing, by White “We’re the TRUE ROLE-Players, not ROLL-Players” Wolf.

Classic games didn’t spend so much time telling you that the “right” way to play is to sit down with friends on a Saturday night so you could spend six hours pretending to be angsty. If you wanted to play a half-rabbit ninja who fought aliens with a home-made try-crossbow, more power to you!